Comment Claude Meetngs (Score 1) 27
Comment Re:This sort of thing is always poop (Score 1) 39
The core idea is a strong point Reddit has been known for, even among people who don't directly use it - Real humans have real discussions about products. Problem, is, advertisers do not want real humans having real discussions, they want 100% astroturf - Which is exactly what Reddit is not known for. I therefore see this going three possible ways - One, they intentionally bias the AI toward only positive reviews; two, this quietly dies a few months from now; or three, Reddit starts aggressively banning the few human users remaining for being advertiser-hostile. All of which make this service useless at best, or more likely this will be just one more minor degradation of everything that once made Reddit great. tl;dr: I actually don't hate the idea, but I'm completely confident the implementation will be a disaster from every possible angle.
Great points. Reading Reddit user comments I helpful because you can distinguish what appears to be real and random rants/ non-problems such as I didn't like that it didn't do x even if it didn't say it did... stuff. Pulling out real value from the junk will be a challenge.
Comment Re:Data poisoning (Score 2) 39
The overwhelming majority of conversations on Reddit are now posted by AI specifically to generate good reviews. This system is doomed to fail as soon as people figure out it cannot be trusted.
Get the popcorn for the fight between bot/paid shill reviewers and people with a grudge against a company or trolls doing it for fun.
Comment Re:Fraud (Score 2) 69
This guy spent 3 years in jail for VAT fraud when he inflated the values of invoices for his movies. Why would anyone trust him enough to work with him?
Yea. Anyone even vaguely associated with Hollywood knows there are perfectly legal ways to make a fortune off of someone else's money.
Comment Don't fuck with the classics (Score 1) 69
Comment Re:Trump is obviously a compromised asset... (Score 1) 717
...for the Democrats.
If he hadn't campaigned so hard for Republicans... if he hadn't told voters to treat the election like he was on the ballot... many of those Republicans might have won re-election.
But we Democrats also need to remember: Trump will not (I hope) be on the ballot in 2028. If we run Congress like people voted for us instead of against Trump, we may rediscover that, as in 2024, the voters are willing to vote against us, too. Heck, we may even rediscover that with the same Presidential nominee...
That's a key point - D's need to get stuff done; even if it means passing legislation that Trump vetos and forcing override votes. I suspect there will be enough R's that see the handwriting on the wall and want to survive 2028 and to do that they need to work with D's and make things better. Will there be 59/6 or so to do that?
Comment Re:If you want to go down a rabbit hole here... (Score 5, Insightful) 36
Don't get mad at Meta, look into how the Supreme Court starting with Sullivan vs New York Times has created a legal environment where public figures like Haidt effectively have almost no recourse to defamation protection unless it is in a very narrow window of extremely blunt bad behavior.
It's the cost of a viable and vigorous free press. If it is easier to sue an win a defamation suit, it becomes a powerful tool to stifle reporting. It's also important to people who post on public forums because lowered protection cultured result in expensive court cases for them as well.
In Meta's case, if they actually did it then that may reach the actual malice level, depending on what was said, but IANAL so who knows?
Comment Re:QWERTY Syndrome (Score 1) 131
or Nash Equilibrium. If EU wants to get away from MS and GOP's flakey tribalism, they have to agree to all (or most) moving at once, and accept a learning curve.
I'd go with Nash Equilibrium here. DVORK is not inherently better than QWERTY for typing speed, although it is less prone to causing RSI. The big downside is the learning curve and making shortcuts like Ctrl-V harder to press.
Comment Re:Users hate software changes (Score 1) 131
To that one user: "Tough shit. You're getting and using the updated software or you can find yourself a new job." Assuming you have that power, of course.
User: The annual report is nit ready because IT forced a software update and it broke the report generation. I tried to warn them but they did it anyway...
Comment Re:good old days? (Score 1) 129
No browser is going to bring back the good old days.
I want Ludwig Plutonium, AFU, Kibo, Serdar Argjic and the Zumabots, Ted Frank, and Joel Furr vs. The Green Card Lawyers...
Comment Re:Fuck These Tests! (Score 1) 84
These organizations are offloading their technology deficiencies onto the poor and incapable user.
I, as a seasoned professional that has seen every trick email that has ever been sent, cannot determine if certain messages are malicious or not. The users will never be able to do it themselves. And punishing them, whether that's reprimand, scolding, mocking, making them resit training, is NOT the right way to do it.
Exactly. IT orgs should put defenses in place to catch the majority of fishing emsils, using sender info,AI to recognize patterns etc. You won’t catch everything but can greatly reduce the chan crew s they get through.
Comment Re:My CORRECTED link to his 2004 article, post-cof (Score 4, Interesting) 22
Comment Re:training on your data (Score 4, Funny) 236
Anthropic is likely training its models with your data. If your data is cruel then the models can become cruel as well.
Considering they likely used credit,
Comment Re:Documentation (Score 1) 59
not to review techical documentation to identify design issues
But this is exactly where AI can actually be useful — so long as you don't depend on it to identify all of the design issues. It can review mountains of information and find things in it you might not have caught. You just can't assume that it will catch everything it "should" — that is, what it should be capable of catching is not necessarily what you are capable of catching.
Yes, and it requires a multi-layerd approach to how they system raises issues. One simple prompt pass is not enough, however a multi-tiered approach can increase teh success rate. It'll never catch everything, and neither will a human, the tool is merely a way to remove much of the grunt work searching though documents so teh analyst can focus on what is important and make it easier ot find where things are referenced.
Meanwhile, that periodic report has requirements, so you're going to have to ask it to write the report, then to review it to see if it met the requirements, then to review its own statements about whether it successfully met each requirement, because it won't do any of that sanity checking without being told to do so.
There are two different types of reports to develop - one that validates meeting requirements and one that is merely reporting results or periodic required reporting. The former is challenging, the later a lot less so, and reducing the time spent on the later frees up time for the former. Of course, many such reports do not need AI since they merely compile data, and that is easy to program in any of a number of tools. AI just adds hype and market cap...